False identity document offences committed by a victim of human trafficking were quashed as they had been committed in the context of a life of repeated trafficking and sexual exploitation. The offences were integral to, and consequent upon, the trafficking and exploitation so as to extinguish culpability.
A defendant convicted of murder at the age of 15 was refused an application to adduce fresh psychiatric evidence aimed at explaining his reasons for maintaining his innocence at trial. His admission of guilt after conviction was tactical and made in order to gain sentencing advantage.
The court considered the safety of the convictions of two victims of human trafficking, for cultivation of cannabis and controlling prostitution for gain respectively, and whether it had been in the public interest to prosecute them.
A fresh inquest was ordered under the Coroners Act 1988 s.13(1)(b) into the death of a 14-year-old child in 1966, as new evidence was available which rendered a further inquest necessary and desirable in the interests of justice.
The court quashed a sentence of imprisonment for public protection imposed for wounding with intent and replaced it with hospital and restriction orders under the Mental Health Act 1983 s.37 and s.41 respectively. The offender had served more than twice the minimum term ordered and the s.37 and s.41 regime was the most effective way of protecting the public and of monitoring his continued treatment.